Common questions asked about Black Lives Matter from the Asian community

Phoebe Chen ’21

What is Police Brutality?

Many of you may have heard about George Floyd’s case. Just a couple weeks ago, a white police officer kneeled on an unarmed black man, George Floyd, until he died from asphyxia which his independent autopsy later showed. However, the reason people are so outraged is because of the frequency of unarmed Black people getting shot by white police. Breonna Taylor, tamir rice, David Mcatee… even just this past week, an unarmed black man in NJ died in the hands of the police. The worst part is that the incredibly large majority of these police suffer no consequences because they are protected under the law.

What is Systemic Racism?

After slavery forcefully ended, White and Black communities were separated through Jim Crow laws. Once these were abolished, Black communities that have been segregated for so long continued to receive Less funding + access to education in contrast to White communities. This is one of the main reasons for the huge socioeconomic gap between races— not because of the common misconception of Black communities being lazy. Systemic racism is literally about the SYSTEM of Black oppression.

Aren’t Violent Protests bad? pt. 1

I don’t like seeing the mass destruction. However, it is important to look at why it’s happening. Black voices have been suppressed for 4 centuries, and repeatedly, the government only institutes change when violence is incurring… the results are evident. Since these violent protests, all 4 of the police involved in Floyd’s death were convicted, and other police involved in similar situations have been fired. Prior to these violent protests, it would be likely that these police would be free. In 2018, out of the 2000 police that shot and killed people, less than 2% were charged with any crime.

Aren’t Violent Protests bad? pt. 2

if we look at these protests on a micro level, it’s easy to see that many of the people who are starting this violence aren’t the protestors themselves but are the people using these protests as an excuse to steal. Those people do not care about the movement, but are just taking advantage of it. Even further, a lot of the police are starting this violence! Many peaceful protestors have been arrested or hurt from the tear gas and pepper spray they are using. Let’s keep in mind that tear gas has been banned in warfare. Also, It is our 1st amendment right to protest peacefully! Just this past week, a peaceful protestor Sarah Grossman died from the tear gas that the police used.

Where do Asian people fit in? pt. 1

You may have had negative or hurtful encounters with the Black community, and I’m not denying those occurred. If they did, I’m sorry, and they should not be condoned. But it is important to look from the macro level what the Black community has done time and time again to help us. As Asian- Americans, we will be eternally grateful for your hard work and effort in getting us where we are. There’s more to this though; let’s look at this from a history perspective.

Where do Asian people fit in? pt. 2

In the Civil Rights Act of 1964, MLK and President Lyndon B Johnson signed this act to stop discrimination based on color, religion, sex, and origin. Before this act, Asian people faced lawful discrimination in schools, housing market, and workplace. Without this act, we would still face segregation in a myriad of public institutions. The Civil Rights Act that the Black community singlehandedly fought so hard for did not have to include the Chinese. But it did, and now is our time to come together and give back.

Graduating in a Broken America

Matthew Wieseltier ’20

May is normally the happiest month of a high school senior’s year. After worrying about the college process for years, come May 1st, they are left to worry about things like who they are going to prom with and what to wear to graduation.

Ask any high school senior what they are worried about right now, and they’ll tell you that they are worried about going for a walk outside because they might transmit the coronavirus to someone in their household. That their grandparents are in a nursing home with a high reported rate of infection. That their loved ones will die a preventable death in a hospital ill-equipped to help them, surrounded by people they do not know.

It is into such an America that the class of 2020 emerges. Caught off-guard by a virus that we were warned about months in advance, America was brought to its knees. Our healthcare system crumbled, with a government that seemed to actively undercut it for selfish political reasons. This administration’s failure to lead a coordinated federal response means that they have the blood of tens of thousands of Americans on their hands.

But the problems do not end there. People across the country have actively protested against lockdown orders meant to protect them, clamoring that their lives and the lives of their fellow citizens are less important than… their right to be less than six feet away from each other? Their right to … what, exactly?

No leader can rule without the support of the people, least of all in a democracy. A president is usually doomed without the support of their own party. So then is this really a problem with just our president? We, as a collective nation, should never have reached the point where a significant portion of our population simply ignores science.

The issues that we face today are not limited to just our leadership. Yes, this grossly incompetent administration could have done any number of things better to save more lives. But our issues run deeper than that. There are systematic, recurring problems in this country. This virus has proved that to both us and the world, crushing the antiquated idea of American exceptionalism. There is nothing exceptional about having the sixth-highest deaths per capita in the world (this statistic according to the Johns Hopkins Coronavirus Resource Center).

There will of course be a reckoning once this is all over. Politicians will fight over who bungled this or that order of personal protective equipment, and blame will be thrown around aplenty for the failures of our healthcare infrastructure. However, once the dust settles, we will still be living in the same broken nation that allowed this crisis to transpire in the first place. There is no group of people, much less a single person, upon whom the blame can be placed for the current state of this country. This crisis is exposing a host of problems that have festered in this country for decades, if not more.

Americans must not look to assign blame, but rather we must begin to fix the host of issues that this crisis has exposed. By now it has become clear that we will not go back to the same society that existed before the pandemic. This new society has the potential to be better than the one that came before it, if only we make it so. We have learned so many valuable lessons during this ordeal about everything from healthcare to racial inequity, from education to the economy. To not learn from these lessons would be irresponsible at best, criminal at worst.

My message to my fellow graduates is as follows: it is important to rethink, but also to repair. It is on us, the next generation of leaders, health experts, and scientists, to bring about the change this country needs. This change is not necessarily political, but rather it is societal. America is no longer on top. Our job is not to maintain this country’s status, but to rebuild that status in the eyes of the world.

It is a common refrain in graduation speeches that it is that class’s turn to go out and change the country, or the world. If that is the case, the Class of 2020 has its work cut out for it.

Disparities: How can teenagers acquire knowledge about them?

Anita Osuri ’22

Similarly to many of you, these past few months at home have been harsh. I adopted numerous hobbies, such as drawing, painting, and running to pass the time. In addition to those hobbies, I have had the opportunity to reflect on our society and the issues that have been strikingly obvious. By observing the news and politicians speaking about these problems, I started to wonder what teenagers can do to aid in resolving these disparities. 

At the beginning of quarantine, I realized that this dire situation had exposed holes in our current government and social system; economic and racial disparities have plagued our nation, and it is our duty as teenagers to step up to help amend these issues. Currently, due to the coronavirus, many low-income workers are especially vulnerable to layoffs, and unfortunately, they do not have the extra privilege many of us have of being able to pay for front door grocery deliveries. According to the CDC, this service costs between $3 to $9, which is a significant burden on people already facing economic issues. In these areas, food insecurity rates have spiked, and people facing financial problems do not have the option to leave crowded cities where there are illness hotspots.

Another point I would like to bring to light is racial disparities. The CDC has revealed that death rates among African American and Hispanic people are unbelievably higher than those of white or Asian people. What is the reason for this? This crisis is mainly due to living conditions, health conditions, and work circumstances. Many of these underrepresented minorities live in densely populated areas where institutional racism is rampant, and there is less social distancing. In addition, these people may live exceptionally far away from grocery stores and medical facilities. One of the most alarming causes is due to lack of sick paid leave, which increases exposure and spread of the virus. According to the CDC, Hispanics have lower rates of access to paid leave than white non-Hispanic workers, which demonstrates the prevalent racial disparities in our society.

So what can teenagers do about these disparities? Oftentimes teenagers feel that they are too young or do not have the power to make a difference about these issues. However, the truth is that as young adults we have so many resources at our fingertips to gain the necessary knowledge. The most crucial action for teenagers to take is to research these issues and become educated on them. Do not judge before seeing all sides of the problems, and be sure to utilize reliable websites such as the CDC and other scientific journals to comprehend the scope fully. For example, google scholar is an exemplary browser to find the latest scientific journals about a wide array of topics. As for websites to avoid, try not to only use evidence from Instagram and Snapchat as those platforms are often rampant with misinformation. Once you have educated yourself on these topics, voice your opinions! Discuss these problems with your peers and come up with plausible solutions. By working together and uniting with other teenagers, we can formulate plans and actions that can be implemented in the future. Think about grassroot initiatives such as helping your neighbor, your religious institution, specific ethnic groups, or particular communities to influence one family at a time. If you are interested in these topics, make sure to attend university conferences and calls to hear other peoples’ opinions and voice your own. Or if you want to view these issues firsthand, be sure to volunteer for some organizations that try to tackle these issues such as the NAACP or Big Brothers Big Sisters. Remember that we are the future, and it is our responsibility to stay educated and become the next generation to face these problems!

unravelled, sewn again

Saanvi Nayar ’22

scraps of identity
too often wrung of pride
basked in heat blazing of privilege
hems picked and pulled
scrubbed with a hatred 
that kills not soft nor subtle nor slow
but a hard, gut-wrenching hatred
that burns and blisters till festered 

and as the sun reaches its peak
a heat so unbearable that
scraps weathered and worn
pinned with slurs that turn to fists
assemble to be hemmed and stitched
though broken and bruised 
tanned by scorched oppression
blood of life splattered
there is strength, resilience,
the vitality of a culture 
rallying rich and fragrant as ever

brought together by cries 
of anger and love and pride
hardened by screams for mercy
the softened gasp of not one life
but futures, families, careers,
too many to count - robbed.
scraps bonded for justice
fostering art of voice, 
of spirit, of action
vibrant and demanding to be heard

stitched with old thread
covered in patches and fabrics anew
for do not forget
as the sun rises again, 
so will we
scrapped in unity
a community built to thrive
under the harshest of heat
and the pledge of allies
beautiful and diverse
stitching arms and hearts
to fight as one.

America, We Have A Problem

Kavin Nakkeeran ’22

These past few weeks have broken us, divided us, hurt us. The United States of America is literally on fire. Atlanta, Bakersfield, Boston, Chicago, Columbus, Dallas, no, this is not a list of major American cities in alphabetical order, this is a list of cities in active protest. In protest to arrest the three other “complicit” police officers who stood by and did nothing as George Floyd was murdered at the hands of a sociopath. In protest against a system, a system that views some as inferior, as a threat, just because of the color of their skin. Because that is what this conversation is about. It is not about looting and rioting, it is not about CNN, nor Antifa. It is about the systematic racism that has fueled this country for so long. 

I, like so many of my peers growing up in Central New Jersey, have a unique perspective on the issue. I consider myself an American to every extent possible, but it is easy to detach myself from hundreds of years of pain and suffering. I can say “they did that” or “that happened” and remove myself from any accountability. But, by living in America, by breathing here, when so many cannot, I, too, am part of the system. 

When my parents, and a lot of others like them, immigrated to America, they saw what was going on and absorbed it. The Americans did Thanksgiving, so every year, they cut up turkey like their American counterparts and feasted on it. They saw the NBA and kids playing pickup games, so they picked up basketball. That’s how they absorbed American culture, by soaking up what they saw. And they saw a system where blacks were inferior to whites, where everyone was fine with what was happening. My dad had never encountered any race but his own before migrating to the US, so why is it that he got uncomfortable when seeing his black neighbors in Atlanta? And I tell them, the system is broken, we have to fix it, but they just say, you don’t understand, that’s just how it works, that’s just how this country is. But that’s just it. In an effort to be accepted, they accepted racism without questions. That’s the difference between me and my parents. They see the world as it is, but I see the world as it should be.

Truth to be told, they are right, that is how the world is. In 2015, the Hamilton project compiled data stating that around 16% of the black population, compared with around 19% of the white population, used drugs. And while drug usage and selling (both roughly at 1%) were equal between the race, black Americans were 6.5 times more likely to be arrested and incarcerated for it on the state level. Let that sink in. If your skin is a darker color, you are 6.5 times more likely to go to jail for the same offense. 

Nobody is saying that every single police officer is inherently racist. But as a whole, the policing system encourages racial profiling and racial targeting, at the expense of hundreds of lives. That is what ACAB and other organizations supporting police reform are, a manifestation of the frustration against the policing system. Any one who believes that the ACAB is arguing for anarchy and death of police officers is just using a strawman because they do not want to accept the truth. Our country is broken. 

But systematic racism goes beyond policing and criminal justice. We think of redlining as something of the past, but in just 2018, two years ago, Reveal from the Center of Investigative Reporting analyzed that black applicants are 2.7 times less likely to be accepted for homeownership than their white counterparts. This report took into consideration nine other economic factors related to banks lending money, but still found that blacks were denied owning property just because of their skin color. 

The list goes on and on, from health laws to employment, but for me, the most important example of institutionalized racism is education. Americans have long believed that equal opportunity will lead to equality. That is why the United States was the first nation to institute widespread public education. But what a lot of people don’t realize is that linking the education system to property taxes leads to unequal opportunity and inequality. The median net worth of a black household is just 17,500 dollars, in contrast with the 171,000 average net worth of white families. This is caused by centuries of slavery and decades of laws that prevented free blacks from owning property and accumulating wealth. But now, we are denying them the right to escape poverty. Lower property taxes lead to less funding for education systems, which then, in turn, is leading to higher dropout rates, all leading back to the lower net worth of black families. There is no break from this cycle, which has perpetuated in black communities from the 19th century.

Obviously, rioting and looting is not the answer to this beyond complex network that works against some. Historically and morally, peaceful protests have always availed. From Gandhi’s liberation of India to Martin Luther King Jr.’s Civil Rights movement, we have succeeded with calm heads and steady voices. Now is not the time to throw that away.

Racism is not political. These protests are not political. This is not a “leftist campaign for the election.” This is about equality. For 8 minutes and 46 seconds, George Floyd was restrained by a knee on his neck. But the truth is, for over 400 years, African Americans have been oppressed by systematic racism. This is a fight to be free.